Civil War (2024)
breakmebad 2 points 15 days ago*.

This movie has caused a Civil War in my brain…. and I don’t really know which side I’m on. On the one hand, it’s a beautiful, searing and poignant drama that asks very hard questions about what modern America is and who we are as a people. On the other hand… it doesn’t attempt to answer those questions, outright pulls it’s punches, and leaves me wanting a lot more meat on the bone.
The cinematography, direction, acting, sound design, set pieces and action sequences are all absolutely phenomenal. 10 out of 10. But the story… it leaves me wanting so much more. I LOVE a great character study, but I feel the broader story/world-building and even the characters themselves needed much more fleshing out. This would have made for an absolutely fantastic mini-series in the same vein as ‘Chernobyl’, but as a movie, I’m not sure it hits like it should. Even so, I was 100% on-board throughout the entire movie, but the last two minutes didn’t sit right with me for reasons I can’t fully explain. Also, Nick Offerman and Jesse Plemons are CRIMINALLY underused. Overall, it’s a 3.5/5, but I’m rating it 4/5.

grasshopper rex 2 points 15 days ago.

Garland intentionally avoided the politics of the conflict. He wanted to show how war brings out the worst in most people and how there are no real winners in these conflicts, especially civil wars. Instead of glorifying it and giving us sides to choose from, we were given a cautionary tale of how our humanity is reduced. No one in their right mind should want this or think there is no other option left to us.