Ty performs life-saving surgery on a mare, while Amy and the family work around- the-clock to bottle feed the mare's twin foals. Meanwhile, Georgie's new coach overhears Georgie confront Sam when she suspects her of sabotage during an Extreme Team practice, and Sam blames Georgie when she loses her headliner status. Forced together on a trail ride, Lou and Mitch come to terms with their mutual attraction and Lou reaches a decision about her future. Adam pushes Georgie to dig deep when she has to write an essay on her "most memorable moment." And when the goldfish Tim buys for Katie suddenly dies, Tim and Jack struggle with how to break the news to her.