Katie is excited to learn that the boys and girls will compete against each other in a charity soccer game to benefit underprivileged kids. Though she is a strong soccer player, Katie is surprised to learn that the boys refuse to believe that the girls will win the game. Katie motivates Emily and fellow her teammates to do their best, but when her skills cause tension with Oliver, who is playing against her, she attempts to weaken her chances of winning the game. Meanwhile, Jesse quickly befriends James, a guest at the Blue Antelope, whose wild and adventurous actions cause Jesse serious injury and lead to tension between Danny and Jo.